The matched-card matrix produced 44 timings in 48 attempts. Shopper Approved Slippers had one desktop-warm run without its star placeholder and one mobile-warm cutoff miss; Shopper Approved Sandals had one desktop-cold cutoff miss. One ReviewsBro Sandals desktop-warm attempt could not be measured by the browser harness. None was silently replaced.
Matched targets: Slippers product 8019283083382 and Sandals product 8019290783862. Both appear in the first 16 ordered products in every measurable run. Observation limits were 25s desktop / 45s simulated mobile from navigation. Vendor order alternated each round; the same card was scrolled to its top after DOMContentLoaded. Shopper Approved readiness requires five styled CSS star spans; ReviewsBro readiness requires the matching cached-rating badge. This observes DOM/computed-style visibility, not completed image paint.
Additional retained Shopper Approved observations · seconds from navigation
| Browser condition | New Arrivals | Tide search |
| Desktop · cold | 7.54s (2/3) | No timing (0/3) |
| Desktop · warm | 6.83s | No timing (0/3) |
| Simulated mobile · cold | Insufficient samples (1/3) | No timing (0/3) |
| Simulated mobile · warm | 6.92s | 9.77s |
Missing observations remain in the attempt counts. New Arrivals had five SA-rated cards but no positive live cache entries. Retained search varied between 24, 48 and 72 cards; live search had 24 cards with four cached ratings. The vendor cohorts do not match. The one mobile-cold New Arrivals observation was 12.13s; it is not shown as a reliable median. These checks used 8s desktop / 16s mobile initial observation floors; browser tasks can extend them. This is a preview observation, not a general claim that Shopper Approved fails to render.
Earlier live cache-only observations · first visible badge in seconds
| Browser condition | Orthotic Sandals | Tide search |
| Desktop · cold | 9.61s | 7.76s |
| Desktop · warm | 5.39s | 4.29s (2/3) |
| Simulated mobile · cold | 11.40s | Insufficient samples |
| Simulated mobile · warm | 5.68s | 3.42s |
Zero AWS review-data reads or review-data failures across all 36 earlier collection/search attempts. Sandals uses three observations per cell. Search desktop warm uses two; one reached its observation cutoff before readiness. Mobile cold search had only one recorded timing (16.94s) and two cutoff misses, so no reliable median is shown. Zero network calls does not mean instant badge display.
Live New Arrivals was tested in 12 cold/warm desktop/mobile runs: 16 cards, no eligible cached ratings, no stars and no review-data requests. That is an unrated-cache state, not a 0ms result.
Chrome 131, one browser at a time. Desktop: 1440 × 1000, unthrottled. Simulated mobile: 390 × 844, 1.6 Mbps download / 0.75 Mbps upload, 150 ms latency and 2× CPU throttle. Images and fonts were allowed; the same advertising hosts were blocked.
Three alternating cold/warm pairs per vendor and device profile. Cold means a fresh browser context; DNS, TLS and CDN caches were not reset. Warm means a new page in the same context. Review readiness was observed on animation frames when review DOM text was populated, not measured as viewport paint.
23 of 24 product-page attempts were valid. Every displayed median uses three valid samples except *Shopper Approved mobile warm, which uses two. One browser-harness failure was excluded; it was not counted as zero or attributed to the widget.
Transfer uses encoded network bytes and excludes browser-cache-served bytes. Vendor files are classified by hostname or asset filename; Shopify HTML, embedded review content, JSON-LD and shared theme traffic are separate. ReviewsBro’s embedded review-section HTML was 11.7 kB uncompressed. Warm external vendor transfer was zero for both systems.
Collection-star visibility is animation-frame-observed viewport intersection and computed display state. It is not a paint measurement. Only positive cached-rating cards enter the eligible cohort; no eligible cards means no timing, never “0ms.” Scrolling is explicit, and general theme scripts can delay badge display even without review-data requests.
The collection/search checks use three cold/warm pairs per profile and page. After DOMContentLoaded, search and New Arrivals scroll to the first grid card; Sandals scrolls to its first cached reviewed card. Sandals had two eligible cards in a 16-card page; search had four in 24. The visible cohort was two/three cards on desktop and one on mobile. Initial observation floors, from navigation before the final bottom scroll, were 8s desktop / 16s mobile for search and New Arrivals, and 15s / 25s for Sandals; browser-task delays can extend these windows. Cutoff misses are disclosed rather than counted as zero or silently replaced. The tests exercised below-the-fold scrolling, not AJAX filter/replacement hydration.
Dates use US Eastern time. Collection and search observations were completed on October 6, 2026 (October 7 UTC).
These lab observations cover this product and the named collection/search pages on this date. They do not establish physical-phone results, field Core Web Vitals, a store-wide average, conversion uplift or performance guarantees. No theme settings, customer submissions or review content were changed by the tests.